The public perceives the suicides of Haryana police officers as symptomatic of systemic corruption and caste discrimination within law enforcement, leading to widespread calls for CBI investigations. There is a strong sentiment of distrust towards the police and political figures, highlighting a deep-seated frustration with the current state of affairs.

Haryana Police

Amit Shah

Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI)

Hello, u/Snehith220! Thank you for your submission to r/CriticalThinkingIndia. We appreciate your contribution to our community.

- If your submission is a photo/video, please provide the source under this comment.
- If your submission is a link, please provide a summary of the information from that link in the comments.

We hope you'll follow our rules and engage in meaningful discussions.

*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/CriticalThinkingIndia) if you have any questions or concerns.*

AutoModerator

BATMAN__1

The sad part is the corrupt is still safe while the truth killed itself.

Kaliyuga indeed, and he'd live to see his fall and whitewashed rise in politics

IcyLow9565

It's heartbreaking to see that honesty chooses to take it's own life unable to thrive in a place as corrupt as India (always has been the case) but it's literally even more disappointing to see a missed opportunity to not take any of the corrupt swines alongwith.

Don't die in vain, people.

mcryan07

It is extremely said to see this, but why choose death. We know this system is not going to change, the only way is to keep fighting. His death caused a nation to lose a honest officer and a loss for his family which cannot be recover. 
I truly respect his stand on the matter but I am really upset about the action he took. I also understand that he took this stance because he see no way out and he was being framed but eventually it caused us more pain. 

Unfortunately, we live in country where leader justify crime, corruption. Rape is justified, murder is justified… 

Sometimes I feel we are the one who cause all this. We allow corruption to grow and then complain when it hit back. 

Nevertheless, it’s a loss of honesty in our country. A country, we call home

Zestyclose-Choice-51

i'm sorry but why has this guy ended himself if puran kumar was corrupt? Like what's the point here?

Known-Issue4970

This is so sad, I hope his family is fine.

Also this is why redditors need to stop acting like judge. This case seems to be getting more and more complex, is YS Puran Kumar's the real evil or is his image being tarnished, is Sandeep Kumar saying the truth or was he pressured to do this, there's just questions and no answers.

I don't think Haryana police will be able to properly investigate this case given the police department itself is involved here, hope this case gets transferred to CBI and actual culprit gets caught and brought to justice no matter who it is.

SpyTheJames

https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/in-haryana-ips-officers-suicide-case-another-suicide-reveals-new-twist-9452488

https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/another-haryana-cop-asi-sandeep-kumar-found-dead-rohtak-ips-y-puran-kumar-alleged-suicide-101760435254692.html

Snehith220

Proud of you. My prayers to this great soul

RevolutionaryOne9459

Both are victims seems like. The rot can be understood that they could threaten another person to commit suicide. Imagine the kind of threat they can possibly do

Bright-Muscle7644

What are the chances that this is a murder and the video is a deepfake? We live in such a world!

IndependentAwkward40

Can anyone give the tldr? I don't understand Hariyanvi that well.

ankool2110

[deleted]

Chowkidaar hi soya hai to ye sab to hona hi hai.

JuniorRK

How can people believe that such a senior IPS officer whose wife is an IAS, whose brother in law is an MLA and who has relations in the Niti Ayog will commit suicide because of caste discrimination? That person had the power to destroy everyone's career and he would commit suicide because of caste discrimination??

cdt_3809

aor2028

Marne wale ki aatma ko shanti de bhagwan...


Lekin kya ye ch*tiyapa nahi ki jis case se koi lena dena nahi hai aur jisme alredy bahut bade afsaar fase hai tab ye ek banda aata hai aur unko clean deta hai aur khud marr jata hai ???? Par bhai kyu....marna kyu tha, kya zinda reh ke expose nahi kar sakte the

Rryan19

How convenient 

The ips who died was an honest civil servant and always used to stand up to his superiors about being discriminated against on the basis of his caste.
We knew him personally.
I don't know why he chose to end his life and stop fighting these corrupt bastards
We all know how corrupt the Haryana police department is.
Funny thing is they released a statement from his P.A. just a day after his death that he was caught getting 2 lakh bribe so he feared being caught bro are you fuckning serious.

When that didn't work out they made this SI the scapegoat and he agreed to this because probably they had some shady stuff on him.And he took the fall

Look around you people this is what this government has brought us to 
Remember the dharmsthala case what happened buried and they turned the case on the whistleblower itself.
Too obvious and convenient.

This government will do anything to protect itself 

May the good IPS Rest in peace

reddituseonlyyy

Alleging Caste discrimination to cover bad deeds is what majority of cases of caste discrimination actually is . Not getting promotion because of bad work, make up stories of caste discrimination. 

SC/ST act was threatened to a gang rape victim family, telling them not to report gang rape. These are barely covered in mainstream media now

Sam_Fisher91

Definitely a cover-up attempt. Reminds me of True Detective Season 2.

RevolutionaryFig9437

Not clear from the article why this cup committed suicide.

rahulthewall

No-Assignment7129

This seems to be either forceful suicide by threatening that ASI or staged suicide to divert attention from ADGP suicide. See how this guy made scapegoat to make accused in the slain AGDP case as innocent. Some officer is saying he is very honest and sincere to make that allegations he made true and divert the attention from corrupt higher ups. That slain ADGP can also be corrupt but that doesn’t make the discrimination correct.

artistic_trash7

See even if that previous officer Puran Singh might have been corrupt, this suicide seems like a perfect cover up...If u'll look at the language of the suicide note it looks like a script out of whatsapp university...The guy heaped praises for Modi in a suicide note

AG_940

This case is very unusual. Like, someone who has the guts to do corruption won't be opting for suicide as their first option and even if the ADGP was corrupt this second suicide makes zero sense. Some very influential people are behind this case for sure.

ReindeerReasonable38

Do these higher up cops think that people are stupid? Why would a random cop commit suicide because another cop was corrupt and that too after the corrupt cop died?

This is a very obvious coverup. Ig movies aren’t far from the truth after all. 

The culprits should be brought to justice. I hope the first cop’s wife who is an IAS officer pursues justice fiercely. 

Any-Recognition-3652

https://preview.redd.it/mbahotlyt3vf1.jpeg?width=800&amp;format=pjpg&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=2ada7f9e22748fae84bdef7f5e38081823ddfc0c

legendofkalel

I mean even if he is right, I didn't understand the point of suicide. 

He could have just lived and helped in investigation of whatever he knew.

Scientifichuman

Designer-Winter6564

Antha corrupt ayithe vrs theeskuntadu enduku chasthaadu

Automatic-Reaction28

Unless public opinion is contained, this case will become a nation wide sensation and a byword for caste discrimination similar to rohit vemula's name.

MostNeighborhood68

Admins pacha kukkalu dont try anything else

If they can harass an IPS and IAS officer like that, imagine how they must treat the common citizen

India desperately needs major bureaucratic reform. No chance we ever become developed with this leech of a system

No-Way7911

Seems like suicide wont protect your loved ones from retaliation from the corrupt officer nexus. 

Agile-Zucchini-1355

This is getting worse by the day. The cover up is really extensive

bhodrolok

These fuckers are investigating themselves. Nice. What a joke.

sas8184

Neechi jaat ka IPS maar gya Haryana main kissi ko kya farq pdega par ab jab uchi jaat ka ASI ko kuch hua to bawal katt gya. Ajeeb desh h.

Puzzleheaded-Ant-912

Hello, u/Gold_Scientist_8860! Thank you for your submission to r/CriticalThinkingIndia. We appreciate your contribution to our community.

- If your submission is a photo/video, please provide the source under this comment.
- If your submission is a link, please provide a summary of the information from that link in the comments.

We hope you'll follow our rules and engage in meaningful discussions.

*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/CriticalThinkingIndia) if you have any questions or concerns.*

Critical thinkers of the subs turning casteist bigots when it comes to sc st

glizzyg-ooned-4269

https://preview.redd.it/368dr4xbh1uf1.jpeg?width=1080&amp;format=pjpg&amp;auto=webp&amp;s=d282f98631dd135af9e065082b8b6e84d1cf9a23

Icy-Economist3526

Then they say in this age and time why caste census is required.

Icy_Pea_7667

Mammoth_Talk5855

And how many people are in jails due to fake SC/ST act cases ?

Available_Candy_6669

There is no probable scenario where a competent police officer face harassment from other officers less competent than him .

He was an accused in a bribery case and when he saw that he's going to be caught he chose the easy way out

botnoobpot

Didn’t we just have a post where the OP claimed we got rid of the caste system? I wonder what happened so quickly that the caste system came back?

lifegrowthfinance

Holy shit, I hope heads roll for this. I still maintain reservation does not and will not cure the ills of casteism but a civilized society has no place for casteism the people who pushed this officer to suicide should be all treated as culpable

One_Butterscotch8981

In any professional set up incompetence will always face harassment.

It's hard to say what he faced but I'm sure it must be there, because I myself have seen a lot of criticism thrown to reserved candidates in front of me.

Reservation if anything is going to promote the hate in the middle class, you need segregation of the population to put it simply on the basis of economic capacity.

Top % of general, obc, sc and st are unreserved and the 30% of seats are reserved for candidates in the lower middle class and bpl should have a different curriculum all together to educate the illiterate. You can't tell me a 2nd gen ias is still in need of reservation, or that a general guy working jobs to support family while in school is the same as them and less deserving.

WildSpaceBound

The deaths of Haryana Police officer Y. Puran Kumar and Assistant Sub-Inspector Sandeep Kumar have sparked controversy, with calls for a CBI investigation following allegations of caste discrimination and harassment.

Investigation into Police Officer Suicides in Haryana

Why This Matters

Public Sentiment Summary

Highlighted Comments

Parties Involved

What the people want